Welcome to Rusty Nickel Brewing Co.
At Rusty Nickel Brewing Co., located in West Seneca, NY, a warm welcome awaits in a rustic atmosphere that feels like home. Established with a passion for craft brewing, this vibrant brewery offers a diverse range of beers, including IPAs, stouts, and unique seltzers, ensuring there’s something for every palate. Customers rave about the friendly staff and the inviting beer garden, perfect for savoring a cold drink on beautiful days. With live events and a strong sense of community, Rusty Nickel isn’t just a brewery; it’s a destination where craft beer enthusiasts and friends gather to create lasting memories.
-
4350 Seneca St, West Seneca, NY 14224 Hotline: (716) 608-6155
Welcome to Rusty Nickel Brewing Co., a charming brewery located at 4350 Seneca St, West Seneca, NY. This local gem embodies the spirit of craft brewing, where every sip tells a story and every visit feels like a warm embrace from family. Known for its vibrant atmosphere and friendly staff, Rusty Nickel stands out as a must-visit destination for both seasoned beer aficionados and casual drinkers alike.
The reviews speak volumes about the remarkable experience awaiting you here:
- Exceptional Service: Guests rave about the welcoming staff, who are eager to guide you through an impressive selection of beers. As customer Tammra S. notes, the staff is "super friendly and helpful," ensuring your choices are tailored to your tastes.
- Diverse Beer Selection: With a variety of styles ranging from stouts to sours, there’s something for everyone. Greg O. emphasizes the great variety available, while Shauna P. enjoyed a unique dessert-like drink, the Cafe Mocha Latte Nitro. This eclectic selection showcases the brewery's dedication to crafting beverages that satisfy diverse palates.
- Inviting Atmosphere: Rusty Nickel’s fun and funky vibe makes it an excellent place to unwind. Whether sitting outside in the beer garden surrounded by flowers or in their quaint bar, visitors feel at home. The outdoor area is dog-friendly, making it an ideal spot for a laid-back outing.
- Community Focus: The brewery fosters a sense of belonging, as highlighted by Katie W., who feels right at home from the moment she steps inside. With a commitment to supporting local business and providing a cozy environment, you're invited to immerse yourself in the warm embrace of this community hub.
Your taste buds are in for a treat with Rusty Nickel's craft brews—the standout being the aptly named "I Remember, Buffalo", a favorite among guests. M. G. enjoyed a diverse flight of beers, while Megan H. delighted in both a seltzer and an orange cream ale, further underscoring the brewery's promise of diversity in flavor.
Food Options: While Rusty Nickel does not have an extensive food menu, patrons can enjoy options from neighboring restaurants. Several reviewers noted delicious bites from local eateries, adding another layer of convenience to any visit. The brewery also occasionally hosts events, like the Sausage Fest, offering guests the chance to sample fantastic local sausages along with their brews.
In conclusion, Rusty Nickel Brewing Co. is more than just a brewery—it's a destination that captures the essence of craft beer culture in a friendly, laid-back setting. Whether you’re stopping by after a trip to Niagara Falls or exploring the beer scene in Buffalo, this charming brewery promises delightful libations, excellent service, and a welcoming atmosphere that will make you return time and again.
Stopped by when we were traveling around Buffalo. Great staff. Super friendly and helpful when selecting beer. Definitely will be back when traveling through Buffalo again.
Great beer selection with multiple styles available. Also have liquor and wine and some food options. I didn't do any of the IPAs while I was here this time but the stouts and lagers I had were all good.
Three of us stopped here after lunch at the Ebenezer Ale House. I was in the mood for something dessert-y/after dinner drink-ish, so I went with the Cafe Mocha Latte Nitro. I'm no beer expert, but I do love coffee and chocolate, so I did enjoy this. I like the creaminess of a nitro, and it also seems to bring out more sweetness. Their website claims "something for every taste", and that's true: beer (draft, bottles, cans), wine, cocktails, seltzers, ciders, mead. If you can't find a beverage that suits your fancy, that's on you. The atmosphere inside and out is fun and funky. The best part of our visit was sitting outside on a beautiful fall day, just relaxing and sipping a cold one.
We love going to small craft breweries where the minute you step in the door, you feel like you are with family. The staff and Owners of Rusty Nickel are doing it all right. The quaint bar with the rustic atmosphere is amazing. I have been to hundreds of breweries and have tried thousands of different craft brews, I have never had a beer at Rusty Nickel that disappointed. I love the variety and flavors they have to offer. Parking lot may look swamped because of the business out front, don't be alarmed, pull in and drive to the back where the brewery is and go in.. you will not be disappointed. Thanks for the hospitality and we will continue to support your local business.
Stopped here after visiting Niagara Falls. They have a nice selection of brews, and heated/covered outdoor space. No food available, but a restaurant next door
I was so happy to stop by today and see Ted behind the bar. A Buffalo legend! So, obviously the service was the best in wny! There is a great selection of varieties of beers on tap, and with our group of 10, we tried a lot of them. I had the seltzer and the orange cream ale. Both are fantastic! Love the beer garden out back. There is a coy pond, gorgeous flowers, tons of patio furniture, and I'm told it is dog friendly too. Cheers!
Tried a variety flight of 6 , sours, ciders, IPA... everything was delicious. The staff were so welcoming to us & the dogs. Great experience !
This was our first visit to Rusty Nickel Brewing Company and definitely won't be our last. The vibe is very relaxed and welcoming. The beer menu is quite diverse with multiple offerings in each category. The beer was very good and well brewed. There were three bartenders working and we received excellent service. We were able to taste a small sample of the beer before ordering a full pint. I loved The Half Slice Orange Vanilla, which tasted like a creamsicle. My husband's favorite was the I Remember, Buffalo. It was a great experience and a fun afternoon.
I'm in love with this place! I wish I could bring it back to California. It was rustic and green and had lovely areas to sit. The beer was good and the all around vibes were lovely. I wish I had more time to go when they actually have live shows as it is obvious this place is a really good time. If I come back to this area I will come back here again!
Place is tiny! But the patio is nice. I think the patio is actually bigger than the inside! Great location to sit outside in the summer. Drink reviews can be found on Untappd. We came here for the Sausage fest hosted by Wardynskis. I'd like to come back again to try their actual food menu. I'm really glad we did not pay extra for a table reservation, because all the tables were full anyways. We ended up outside on the patio. One portion was covered with a tent, but standing tables only. The other portion was not covered, but it was blocked off my tarp to minimize the cold/wind. Both outdoor sections were heated, but the uncovered section that had the chairs was much colder. I do love that they walked around with free samples of sausage, and I really enjoyed being able to try different types of meat blends. Reuben sausage 10/10 This was absolutely amazing, I would buy this and eat this every week at my house. It tasted exactly like corned beef. Cooked great and juicy. Just a really great sausage. Jalapeño cheddar chicken sausage 8/10 Totally not used to chicken sausage, but the flavor was decent, not super spicy but it was there. And it was cooked super well, very juicy. Lamb sausage 10/10 Great flavor, and great cook. Cajun venison sausage 10/10 Kyle. 5/10 Kim. Extremely weird texture for me, I could not get past 1 small bite.. and idk if Cajun mixed with it all that well. On the other hand, Kyle loved it. Yankee BBQ brisket platter 9/10 Brisket was good. Juicy and cooked great. Would have loved a roll or something with it or maybe as a sandwich. I ended up making a sandwich at home with my leftovers (brisket, Mac and cheese and coleslaw, it was amazing all 3 in the same bite) Italian sausage sandwich 10/10 Kyle. 7/10 Kim. Had a slightly weird flavor than I was used to. Kyle loved it. It was a pretty big link too. Mac and cheese 7/10 It was pretty cold by the time it took to get it and then walk it to our outside table, so hard to judge the flavor since it wasn't at its prime temperature, but I feel like it was good. Lot of pepper in it though, you couldn't taste it a ton but more than I would have liked. Coleslaw 9/10 I don't like coleslaw too much, but this one was good. There was lots of pepper in this as well. Whoever made the sides was very heavy on the pepper.